A red excavator and other equipment in a quarry
The EU’s energy transition plans depend on critical raw materials. A research project is examining strategies to help Europe become less dependent on the global market and less affected by geopolitical tensions. © Danish Puri/unsplash+

They’re used for instance in wind turbines, solar panels, and batteries. The so-called critical raw materials – such as rare earth elements, lithium, copper, aluminum, zinc, cobalt, and nickel – are indispensable for achieving the EU’s climate goals. The problem is that hardly any are found in Europe – and trading in them is becoming increasingly complex.

In the context of the FWF-funded project “Europe’s mineral trade and global energy transition”, a research team at the University of Klagenfurt has examined how recent geopolitical developments are affecting trade in critical raw materials, how risk assessment can be improved – and what Europe can do to ensure its security of supply.

Principal investigator Dmitri Blüschke from the Institute of Economics, Analytics, and Operations Research at the University of Klagenfurt uses a simple example to explain Europe’s dilemma. A central component of the “European Green Deal” is the electrification of transportation, which has so far been largely powered by fossil fuels. So-called rare earth elements are essential components in electric drives, as well as in wind-turbine magnets. However, 98 percent of these come from China – a country that primarily pursues its own political and economic interests and pays little heed to the well-being of Europeans.

Europe's trade in raw materials

Critical raw materials are essential for clean energy technologies such as electric vehicles, wind turbines, and photovoltaics. Secure access to these resources is therefore crucial for Europe’s energy transition. This study examines how geopolitical risks affect trade in mineral resources and the ability of European countries to advance the energy transition. 

A researcher in a blue short-sleeved shirt is standing next to a large globe
The economist Dmitri Blüschke is working on new methods for producing higher-quality data in order to analyze global trade in commodities and the policy options available to the EU. © University of Klagenfurt

Crises, wars, Trump

Similar dependencies, albeit less pronounced, exist for copper, lithium, aluminum, and nickel. The EU’s Critical Raw Materials (CRMs) Act lists more than 30 raw materials – and for the vast majority of them the EU depends on the goodwill of exporting countries and functioning supply chains that have become increasingly unreliable in recent years, be it due to wars, pandemics, extreme weather events, or the erratic actions of the U.S. president.

In Blüschke’s opinion, this makes his research complex, but all the more interesting and relevant. “Purely from my perspective as a researcher, I should almost be grateful to Donald Trump. It is probably unintentional, but he demonstrates why our research is so important.” For, forecasting models that were commonly used in the past have become increasingly unreliable – if not downright obsolete – owing to the developments of recent years. Consequently, there is a need for researchers who are exploring new models.

“In the long term the EU must invest more in its own research.” Dmitri Blüschke

A lot of data, but very little good data

As Blüschke explains, the research project can be roughly divided into three phases. The first phase involves collecting relevant data and identifying gaps in the methodology. The problem: “There’s a lot of data, but very little truly good data.” In order to analyze potential impacts on global trade, many researchers rely on the Geopolitical Risk Index, which automatically analyzes media coverage and creates a situational overview on that basis. This said, the Index draws only on North American publications.

In a second step, Blüschke and his colleagues are therefore developing new categories and methods to generate data of higher quality. If one wants to avoid describing only the North American perspective, it is essential to also analyze Chinese and European publications.

What’s next?

The final, still outstanding, phase of the project addresses the heart of the matter. Blüschke – who finds it hard to conceal his enthusiasm for such analyses – intends to use game theory to analyze the options for action and strategies in global commodity trade employed by various political stakeholders.

Based on this analysis, the research team will draw up policy recommendations. While Blüschke does not want to go out on a limb at this point, he is ready to offer some insights of a more general nature. In order to reduce dependencies, Europe must diversify its sources of raw materials. Recently the EU has, for instance, concluded trade agreements with Canada, Chile, and Australia, all of which sit on large reserves of copper and aluminum. Blüschke considers this a step in the right direction.

In the long term, Blüschke emphasizes, the EU must invest more in its own research – particularly in the areas of batteries and energy storage – to reduce its dependencies on the global market and geopolitical developments. This research project is set to run until July 2028. Until then, the geopolitical situation is likely to provide plenty of “interesting material” for the researchers.

About the researcher

Dmitri Blüschke has been an associate professor at the Institute of Economics, Analytics, and Operations Research at the University of Klagenfurt since 2018. The research of Blüschke, an economist with venia docendi, focuses on macroeconomics and game theory. Since 2013, he has been a member of the German Network on New Economic Dynamics (GENED), which focuses on the development and application of computer models for analyzing complex economic developments.

About the project

A research team at the University of Klagenfurt is analyzing how geopolitical tensions that affect trade in critical raw materials impact the global energy transition. Their findings will be used to develop tangible strategies in order to ensure the security of supply of critical raw materials in an unstable international environment. Funded by the Austrian Science Fund FWF, the project is set to run until July 2028.